Bakesale Betty
5098 Telegraph Ave
Oakland, CA 94609
(510) 985-1213
http://www.bakesalebetty.com
I have an above-average love for fried chicken, preferably in boneless form. When I was little, I would always order chicken tenders whenever we ate out – who needed burgers when you could eat strips of breaded, juicy, crunchy chicken dipped in honey mustard or (even better) ranch?
(Don’t talk to me about Chicken McNuggets. I shudder at the thought. I remember my parents trying to force me to eat Chicken McNuggets when I was 4 years old or so. I gagged as I chewed the spongy/bouncy/soggy fried nuggets composed of mysterious chicken parts. After I threw up, my parents wisely never forced Chicken McNuggets on me again.)
See? Discerning food snob even at age 4.
Anyways, back to my love of fried chicken. I remember when Bakesale Betty opened, sometime when I was still in school in Berkeley. I remembered stopping by one day to check out the fried chicken sandwiches. I took one bite, then another. Then I wolfed the whole thing down. Never mind that it made me too full for dinner later that day.
To make a long story short, this fried chicken sandwich became a regular habit of mine. And that’s high praise coming from a self-avowed fried chicken lover.
By the time I left Berkeley for southern California, the word had spread about Bakesale Betty’s fried chicken sandwiches and they were regularly selling out of them. I always had to make sure that I came at the beginning of the lunch rush, or I’d be out of luck.
So I was eager to reacquaint myself with one of my favorite Berkeley sandwiches on this return trip. Little did I know that word had spread so far and wide about the charms of Bakesale Betty’s sandwich that there would now be lines stretching down the block at lunchtime for people waiting for the fried chicken sandwich!
I guess this line was a surprise to no one but me, as a poet had set up shop outside Bakesale Betty, presumably to capitalize on the captive audience waiting in the lunch line.
The proprietor in her immediately-recognizable blue wig came out. Last time I was here (in 2006), it was just her and her husband and some employees running the shop. This time, she was carrying her baby in a front pouch while bustling about. Aww, life’s changes.
Even though they’ve hired many more employees since I last came in 2006, the employees seem to be no less busy!
I ordered a sandwich and strawberry shortcake, my two old favorites. Weaving my way through the crowd of people inside as I clutched my heavy, prized bag of sandwich and shortcake, I made my way outside, where I sat at one of the colorfully-painted ironing boards serving as tables, enjoyed basking in the hot autumn sun for a few minutes, and then started chowing down.
The strawberry shortcake was soft and slightly moist / cakey, topped with sugared strawberries, runny with juice, and unsweetened whipped cream.
Ok, I’ll cut to the chase and talk about this chicken sandwich. Juicy, firm, and slightly dry chicken breast. Generous portion. Perfect breading on the chicken – spicy, crispy, and pleasantly moist with olive oil from the coleslaw.
And then – the coleslaw. I dislike most mayo-based slaws because, well, I don’t really like mayo. Which is why I love Bakesale Betty’s version so much. Crunchy cabbage with slivers of red pepper. Lubricated with a healthy dose of olive oil. Slightly tangy. No mayo in sight – truly a beautiful thing.
And the bread? Soft, untoasted yet substantial, these rolls are from Acme Bakery (my favorite bakery in the Bay Area). They are soft enough to yield without crunching (leaving the job of providing crunch up to the fried chicken and coleslaw), but they have a firm enough crumb to stand up to the oily dripping goodness of the coleslaw and the juiciness of the chicken.
Everything was delicious and exactly as I remembered it, even three years later. I guess sometimes food does live up to the hype you create in your fond memories of the past.